Elixir Audits, Chartered Accountants

Payroll errors are systematic rather than occasional. Whatever is wrong is wrong every month, for every affected employee, until somebody looks. That is why a payroll review is where a GRA officer starts and why the assessments are larger than people expect.

The four we find most often

Benefits in kind not grossed up: vehicles, accommodation, fuel and allowances treated as cost rather than as employment income. Bonus taxed wholly at the graduated rates when the first 15% of annual basic qualifies for a 5% final rate, or the reverse. Tier 3 relief applied above the 16.5% cap. And expatriate employees taxed on the wrong basis entirely, which is the most expensive of the four.

SSNIT and the PAYE base

The employee's mandatory 5.5% contribution on basic salary is deducted in arriving at chargeable income, so PAYE is charged on the reduced figure. Voluntary Tier 3 contributions are also relievable up to 16.5% of basic. A surprising number of payroll systems in use in Ghana get this wrong and overstate the tax, which is an error in the employee's disfavour and still an error.

Why this is a tax service and not a payroll service

Running the payroll is a different engagement, and we do that too under Accounting and People. This service is about whether the treatment is correct and whether the exposure has been quantified. Many clients keep payroll in-house and use us only for the review.

15th

PAYE and withholding tax, for the previous month

5.5%

Employee SSNIT, deducted before PAYE is computed

15%

Of annual basic, the bonus threshold taxed at a final 5%

Scope

What the review covers

Scoped to the periods still open, and to the categories where exposure actually accumulates.

01

Payroll tax review

Testing PAYE, SSNIT and Tier 3 across a sample of employees and months, reconciled to the general ledger and to what was actually filed and paid.

02

Benefits in kind

Identifying what has been provided, whether it has been treated as employment income, and quantifying the exposure where it has not.

03

Expatriate and non-resident taxation

Residence analysis, the basis of taxation, treaty considerations where they apply, and coordination with work permit and immigration positions.

04

Remediation and disclosure

Correcting the treatment going forward and, where historic exposure is material, quantifying it and advising on voluntary disclosure.

Process

How the review runs

Short, and it produces a number rather than a list of observations.

If the GRA has already writtenCall before responding. Payroll reviews move quickly because the records are predictable, and what you hand over first shapes what remains arguable.

Records request

Payroll registers, the general ledger, filed returns and payment evidence for the periods under review.

Week 1

Testing

Sample-based across employees and months, covering gross to net, statutory deductions and benefits.

Weeks 1 to 2

Quantification

Exposure by category and by period, with the assumptions stated so it can be challenged.

Week 3

Remediation plan

Corrections going forward, system and process changes, and a view on disclosure where historic amounts are material.

Week 3

Follow-up

Retesting a later month to confirm the corrections took effect.

One quarter later

Engagement

Fees, timing and who does the work

Fee basis

Fixed feeSet on headcount and the number of periods reviewed. Remediation quoted separately once the position is known.

Who does the work

Tax manager, partner reviewedWith a partner on any disclosure decision.

Timeline

Two to three weeksFrom receipt of complete payroll records.

Indicative only. Every fee is quoted in the proposal, before any work starts, and held unless the scope changes.

Questions

Questions on employment taxes

Is SSNIT deducted before PAYE?
Yes. The employee's mandatory 5.5% contribution on basic salary reduces chargeable income, so PAYE is charged on the lower figure. Tier 3 contributions are also relievable up to 16.5% of basic. Several payroll systems get this wrong and overstate the tax.
How is a bonus taxed?
A bonus of up to 15% of annual basic salary is taxed at a final rate of 5%. Anything above that threshold is added to employment income and taxed at the graduated rates. Getting the split wrong on a large bonus is a common source of assessments.
What counts as a benefit in kind?
Vehicles, accommodation, fuel, and allowances that are not reimbursements of actual business expenditure. If the employee receives value they would otherwise have paid for, it is likely employment income and should be through payroll.
How are expatriate employees taxed?
It depends on residence, the source of the income and whether a treaty applies. Non-residents are taxed at a flat 25% with no bands and no personal reliefs. This is the category where we find the largest single errors, because the analysis is genuinely harder.
Can you run our payroll as well?
Yes, though as a separate engagement under Accounting and People. Many clients keep payroll in-house and use us only for the annual review, which is a sensible arrangement if the processing itself is reliable.

Next step

Send us three months of payroll registers.

We will tell you whether the treatment is right and quantify anything that is not, before somebody else does.

Request a payroll tax review Speak to a partner

Contact

+233 53 362 2433 info@elixiraudits.com

1 Alex Nkrumah Street, Airport West, Accra